Rehiring five roles after a layoff without a hiring function
Call your alumni first, open the rest on pay-per-hire terms, and keep the free tools after the push; a one-time spike of five hires does not justify a salary.
Start with five phone calls, not five job posts. The people you laid off cost no fee and no ramp, and in my example three of them come back. The two roles that stay open go out on pay-per-hire terms, $31,000 each at 20% of $155,000, owed when they start. Nobody gets hired to run the push.
Rehiring five roles after a layoff
A layoff last year, budget this year, five roles, no recruiter, and no wish to build a hiring function for a spike that ends in a quarter. That situation has a shape most advice ignores: a push with an end date. A hiring function is a fixed cost, and a fixed cost is the thing you just cut.
So the push runs on variable cost, and on the one asset a rebuilt company has that a new one does not: a list of people who already know the work. Here is the calendar I would run.
| Week | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1 | Tell the team, then call every alumnus you would rehire |
| 2 | Brief, salary band and fee for each role still open |
| 3 to 8 | Outside recruiters submit, you run one loop per role |
| 6 to 12 | Offers, notice periods, first days |
The example I will price: five roles, three in engineering and two in customer success, at an average base of $155,000 with engineering pulling the average up. Five outside hires at a 20% fee would be $31,000 each, $155,000 in all, which is one whole salary spent on finding five people. What follows is how to pay two of those fees instead of five, and none of them before anyone starts.
The people you let go are the cheapest channel
Most advice treats a rehire like any other push: post the roles, start fresh, and do not look back at the people you let go. The default exists for a reason. Calling someone you laid off is awkward, a few of them are angry, and a job post spares you the call.
I think the awkward call is the best-priced hour in the whole push. An alumnus costs no fee, no sourcing, no screening and no ramp. Recruiters call them boomerangs. I call them the only candidates who have already passed your interview. ADP Research's May 2025 note on boomerang hiring, drawn from its own payroll data, has returning employees at 35% of all new hires in March 2025, up from 31% a year earlier, and at nearly two-thirds of new hires in the information sector.
The saving lives in the soft cost. SHRM's 2022 piece on recruiting costs puts an average hire at nearly $4,700, about 60% of it soft cost, mostly managers' time. An alumnus skips most of it. No sourcing, one conversation instead of three, references you already hold, and a first week that starts in the codebase instead of the wiki.
In the example, three of the five say yes. That is generous and I know it; plan on one or two. Even one changes the bill by $31,000, which is more than any negotiation over the fee percent will save you on the same role.
How to ask an alumnus to come back
The call comes from the founder, not from HR, and it has four parts. If your severance paperwork says anything about rehiring, read it before you dial.
Say what changed, in facts rather than pitch: the revenue, the runway, the customer that signed, whatever made the budget real. They watched the company decide it could not afford them. They need to hear that the decision was about a number, and that the number is different now.
Say what the role is now. It may not be the role they had. If it is bigger, say so. If it is the same role with a smaller team around it, say that too, because they will find out in week one.
Offer the band you would pay a stranger. Some of them landed somewhere that pays more, and a few are still looking. Do not price the second group lower because you can. The one who takes a discount to come back resents it by month three, and the team always finds out what everyone makes.
Accept no as a normal answer, and ask for a name. A no from an alumnus who still likes you tends to arrive with the best referral you will get in the whole push. Five calls at an hour each, with half an hour of preparation before each one, is a week-one cost of about eight hours, all of them yours.
The one-time push priced two ways
The alternative to the calls is rebuilding a function for six months: a contract recruiter, a subscription ATS, and a plan to let both go in month seven. Price it honestly. A fractional recruiter runs about $80 an hour, the rate HeroHunt's July 2026 write-up reports for Dover's, and five open roles is a 30-hour week. Six months is 780 hours, or $62,400, paid whether or not the roles fill, before the subscription and before the two to four weeks the recruiter spends learning what you do.
| Rebuild for six months | Alumni first, then per hire | |
|---|---|---|
| Paid before anyone starts | $62,400 in recruiter hours | $0 |
| Paid when they start | $0 | $62,000, two fees at 20% of $155,000 |
| If nobody comes back | still $62,400 | $155,000, five fees |
| Left in month seven | a contractor to release and a subscription to cancel | a free ATS with the pipeline in it |
Two things jump out. With three alumni back, the two paths cost almost the same money, and only one of them spends it before anyone starts. With nobody back, the fixed path is cheaper on paper by about $93,000, provided the contractor fills all five roles inside six months. That is the assumption doing the work, and it is the same assumption that built the last function.
The percent is yours to set, and on a push that matters more than on a single hire. At 15% the five-fee case is $116,250; at 20% it is $155,000. Pick the percent that gets good recruiters onto the roles and go no higher, because every point is paid five times.
Chosen is the second path, so read this paragraph knowing who wrote it. On Chosen you open the roles that stayed empty after the calls, set a fee on each, and approved recruiters work them into one pipeline. A person at Chosen reads each packet before it reaches you, you owe nothing while a role sits open, and the ATS is free to keep after the push. Two limits, stated plainly. Chosen does not guarantee that any role will be filled. The calls come first for that reason. Chosen is small: 13 approved recruiters in September 2026, so it is one source of candidates, not the only one.
What to keep after the push
Keep the tools that cost nothing to keep, and the lists that took a quarter to build. Four things.
The alumni list, including everyone who said no this time and why. The briefs, one per role with the band, because the next push will reuse four of the five. The pipeline, meaning every candidate who reached a work session, in the ATS and tagged, since the runner-up for the engineering role is the first call the next time it opens. And the names of the recruiters whose packets turned into hires.
Drop everything with a monthly line: the contractor, the subscription, the retainer you were offered in week two. A hiring function you are not using costs the same as one you are.
On Chosen the ATS is free, and there is no cap on roles, seats or candidates. If the old recruiter left an ATS behind, a person at Chosen moves your candidates, roles and stages in from it while it keeps running, so the push starts with the pipeline you already have. When the five are hired, nothing gets cancelled, because nothing was billed.
Hiring back into a team that was cut
The people who stayed have been doing five people's work for a year. They will notice the new hires before they notice the plan, so the plan has to reach them first. Three rules.
Tell the survivors before the alumni calls and before any role goes up. Say what the budget is tied to and what happens to it if the revenue slips. They will hear about the roles from a former colleague otherwise, which is the worst possible way.
Do not rehire above the people who stayed. If the band for a returning engineer is higher than what the engineer who carried the year makes, fix that person's pay first. Compression after a layoff is how you lose the survivors six weeks after the rehires start, and it is the one cost here that is invisible until it lands.
Let the returning alumni carry the message. Three former colleagues walking back in say, better than any all-hands, that the cut was about money and the money is back. The two outside hires arrive into a team that already believes it.
Make the five calls this week, before a single role goes up.
Questions people ask next
Our only recruiter just quit with six open roles. What do we do?
Sort the six by which hire unblocks the most, run the top three yourself with a written brief and one loop each, and open the rest on pay-per-hire terms so nothing is owed until someone starts. Replace the recruiter only once you know the six will become twelve.
What are my options for hiring three engineers in two months with no recruiter?
Four. Do it yourself, about 100 hours; pay a contract recruiter by the hour, hire or no hire; pay an agency a percent of salary at the start, around the 20 to 25% HeroHunt reports for Paraform; or set your own percent on a marketplace, paid at the start. Run your network and one pay-on-hire channel from day one.
Is there a free ATS for a 12-person startup?
Yes. Chosen's ATS is free for every company, with no cap on roles, seats or candidates, and Chosen is paid only when a marketplace hire starts. At 12 people the test of any free tool is whether it holds the whole pipeline, candidates, stages and scheduling, so nobody drifts back to the spreadsheet.
Sources
- Boomerang hiring makes a comeback, ADP Research. Accessed Sep 30, 2026
- The real costs of recruitment, SHRM. Accessed Sep 30, 2026
- Paraform pricing and alternatives 2026, HeroHunt. Accessed Sep 30, 2026
- Hiring through the marketplace, Chosen help center. Accessed Sep 30, 2026